Lighting Product Comparison

Compare two products and calculate luminaire efficacy, or convert lumens and input watts using a supplied matching efficacy.

Bring the specifications together

Start with what you have. Leave unknown specifications blank. The information you enter stays in this page and is not sent to a server.

Already have a matching lm/W value? Convert lumens and input watts using your supplied efficacy.

Results update as you edit.

Calculating needs JavaScript. The form becomes available when its script is ready; the guide below is always readable.

Product comparison inputs

Product comparison inputs
A Product A
Optional. Otherwise the result uses Product A or Product B.
Include the exact model or variant.
Optional HTTP or HTTPS address. The page does not fetch or verify it.
For example, the selected CCT and power setting.
Source lumens and complete luminaire lumens are different. This calculator only calculates efficacy for complete luminaires.
Positive decimal, without commas. Leave blank if not provided.
Use the whole luminaire input, including its required driver, for luminaire efficacy.
The lm and W describe this same model and operating setting. The W includes its required driver input. This is your declaration, not verification by Aulumens.
Other specifications and your notes
Copy the stated value or options, for example 3000 / 4000 K.
Copy the stated metric and value, for example Ra ≥90.
Copy the manufacturer’s statement, including asymmetric angles.
Include units and identify the dimension, for example 90 mm cut-out.
Copy the stated conditions. “Dimmable” alone does not prove compatibility.
Record what matters to your task. These notes are not automatically assessed.
B Product B
Optional. Otherwise the result uses Product A or Product B.
Include the exact model or variant.
Optional HTTP or HTTPS address. The page does not fetch or verify it.
For example, the selected CCT and power setting.
Source lumens and complete luminaire lumens are different. This calculator only calculates efficacy for complete luminaires.
Positive decimal, without commas. Leave blank if not provided.
Use the whole luminaire input, including its required driver, for luminaire efficacy.
The lm and W describe this same model and operating setting. The W includes its required driver input. This is your declaration, not verification by Aulumens.
Other specifications and your notes
Copy the stated value or options, for example 3000 / 4000 K.
Copy the stated metric and value, for example Ra ≥90.
Copy the manufacturer’s statement, including asymmetric angles.
Include units and identify the dimension, for example 90 mm cut-out.
Copy the stated conditions. “Dimmable” alone does not prove compatibility.
Record what matters to your task. These notes are not automatically assessed.

Convert with a supplied luminaire efficacy

If you already have a matching lm/W figure, calculate luminous flux from input power or input power from luminous flux. This is conditional arithmetic; it does not predict a real product's performance.

Results update as you edit.

Calculating needs JavaScript. These inputs become available when their script is ready; the guide below is always readable.

Conditional efficacy conversion inputs

Conditional efficacy conversion inputs
The supplied efficacy must apply to the known quantity. Changing direction does not change the product comparison.
Use a stated or explicitly assumed value for the complete luminaire at the same operating setting. No lamp-type average is selected.
Positive output for the same complete luminaire and operating conditions as the supplied efficacy.
Positive electrical input including the required driver, on the same basis as the supplied efficacy.
Record the product or assumption, source, operating setting and complete-luminaire boundary including its required driver input.
This is your declaration. An efficacy from another lamp, driver or dimming state cannot establish the missing product specification.

Continue your task

Request missing data from the comparison record. Keep values calculated from supplied efficacy labelled as calculations, separate from manufacturer specifications.

If this answers your question within the model’s limits, record the original inputs, unrounded result and conditions. Otherwise choose an action only when its condition applies:

See this task in the decision tree

Opening another tool does not transfer or store your entries. Keep the original values, units and conditions with the next calculation.

What does lm/W tell you?

Lumens describe stated light output; watts describe electrical input. A lower wattage alone does not tell you whether two lights provide the same output. Dividing lumens by watts gives luminous efficacy: the amount of stated light output per watt of input. YourHome’s lighting guidance explains this distinction between output, power and efficacy.

For a household comparing two data sheets, lm/W answers one question about resource use. It does not describe where the light goes. Two products with the same output and efficacy can distribute light differently, so they can produce different light levels on a kitchen bench.

Colour temperature, CRI, beam angle, dimensions and dimming statements add context rather than changing this ratio. They remain separate attributes in the comparison. For help interpreting those entries, see How to compare lighting specifications.

How the calculation works

For a complete luminaire:

Luminaire efficacy (lm/W) = luminaire luminous flux (lm) ÷ luminaire input power (W).

The lumen and watt figures must describe the same model, operating setting and whole-luminaire basis. Input power must include the required driver. Dividing a light source’s output by a complete fitting’s input mixes measurement boundaries: it does not establish the complete luminaire’s efficacy. Likewise, pairing output at one selectable setting with power at another describes neither setting reliably.

Your declaration is recorded as a condition of the calculation. Aulumens does not fetch or independently verify the product data. If the figures describe a lamp or light source, or their basis is unknown, the table retains them but does not calculate efficacy.

Lumen and watt entries must be finite decimal numbers greater than zero. A blank entry means missing information, not zero. Invalid entries need correction before the comparison can be shown.

Why do changes to lumens and watts matter?

At fixed input power, greater luminous flux increases lm/W in direct proportion. At fixed luminous flux, greater input power reduces lm/W because more power is needed for the same stated output. If both quantities change by the same factor, their ratio stays the same. These are comparisons between declared data pairs, not predictions of how a real lamp will behave when dimmed or switched to another setting.

Convert lumens and watts with a supplied efficacy

Lumens measure light output and watts measure power, so neither quantity determines the other by itself. A supplied luminous efficacy connects them for a particular product and operating condition. Rearranging the same ratio gives:

  • Input power (W) = luminous flux (lm) ÷ supplied efficacy (lm/W).
  • Luminous flux (lm) = supplied efficacy (lm/W) × input power (W).

For example, an artificial efficacy of 120 lm/W and an output of 1500 lm give 1500 ÷ 120 = 12.50 W. At the same assumed efficacy, 10 W give 120 × 10 = 1200 lm. At a fixed 1500 lm, changing the supplied efficacy to 100 lm/W raises the calculated input to 15 W. These are conditional arithmetic examples, not measured products or typical LED performance.

Use a documented complete-luminaire efficacy at the relevant model, driver and setting. A light-source-only value does not include the whole fitting’s optical and driver losses. The conversion does not choose an efficacy from the words LED, halogen or incandescent. A broad technology average would hide the missing product information rather than establish a reliable conversion.

The calculated lm or W stays separate from the two-product specification record. It is derived from your supplied efficacy, rather than an independently measured or manufacturer-stated value. Keep that distinction and the source conditions when using a result in an energy and running-cost calculation. Power includes the required driver input for the declared operating state; this relationship does not infer standby consumption.

Efficacy can change with operating conditions. Holding it constant while varying W describes the stated assumption; it does not predict a luminaire’s dimming response. For settings between matching measured lm and W data pairs, use Measured Dimming Curve Interpolation. Neither calculation establishes equal beam distribution, work-surface lux, colour quality or replacement suitability.

Worked example

These are invented arithmetic examples, not actual products or recommended performance targets. Assume each pair describes a complete luminaire at one matching operating setting, including its driver input.

Example Luminous flux Input power Luminaire efficacy
A 900 lm 9 W 100 lm/W
B 1200 lm 9 W 133.33 lm/W
C 900 lm 12 W 75 lm/W

For A, 900 ÷ 9 = 100. For B, 1200 ÷ 9 = 133⅓; the displayed value is rounded to two decimal places. The calculation keeps its internal precision. A positive result below 0.01 lm/W is shown as “<0.01 lm/W” rather than zero.

Compared with A, B states more lumens for the same 9 W, so its efficacy is higher. C states the same 900 lm as A but uses 12 W: 900 ÷ 12 = 75 lm/W. C has lower efficacy even though the stated total output is unchanged. These figures do not establish better lighting at a task surface or make one example the better choice for a particular space.

Interpret the result

Read the data level, source and operating-setting notes alongside each figure. Not provided identifies a missing entry. An uncalculated efficacy has a reason: missing figures, an unsupported data level or an unconfirmed basis.

A comparison can be useful even when one product has incomplete information. Use the gaps to decide what to ask the supplier or manufacturer. Do not treat the other product’s value as a default for a missing entry.

The result does not calculate task-surface illuminance, light coverage or room layout. It does not assess glare, wiring, insulation coverage, wet-area suitability, installation fit, dimmer compatibility or Australian compliance. The methodology explains these calculation and evidence boundaries.

FAQs

Why has no efficacy been calculated?

Check that both lm and W are provided, that they describe a complete luminaire, and that you have declared a matching model, operating setting and whole-luminaire basis. Lamp-only or unknown-level figures can still be recorded but are outside this calculator’s efficacy calculation. If the source does not establish the required conditions, leave the declaration unselected and obtain clarification.

Does a higher lm/W figure mean a product is more suitable?

It indicates more stated light output per watt for the supplied conditions. Suitability also depends on the activity, distribution, colour characteristics and installation requirements. This calculator does not combine those attributes into a score or recommend a product.

How do I compare horticultural PPF and photon efficacy?

Use the PPF mode in Lighting Schedule Totals with one row for each product and a count of one. It keeps 400–700 nm photon flow and matching system input power together, reports each group’s µmol/J and calculates a correctly weighted combined value. This photometric comparison record retains lumens and lm/W; those values cannot be relabelled as PPF or photon efficacy. A receiving-plane PPFD measurement is a different quantity from a whole-luminaire PPF rating.

Related reading

Related tools

Beam Spread Geometry

Solve ideal circular beam geometry on a perpendicular plane, or a tilted cone’s finite ellipse. Geometry does not establish lighting adequacy.

Inputs and results
Inputs
Full cone angle, axial distance or perpendicular diameter; tilted-ellipse mode also requires axis tilt from the plane normal.
Results
Conditional circle geometry, or ellipse major/minor diameters, area and centre offset.

Lighting Energy and Running Cost

Estimate lighting kWh and usage cost with simple comparisons, mixed operating states, or different day types and seasonal schedules.

Inputs and results
Inputs
Counts, input W, non-overlapping state hours, specified days and optional usage rates; group IDs and mutually exclusive day-type counts where used.
Results
Energy in kWh and conditional usage cost in AUD; simple-mode A-minus-B differences or combined state/day-type totals.

LED Strip Cut-length Planner

Plan repeated identical LED strip lengths from a supplied cut interval, choosing not to exceed or to reach a target, with optional matching per-metre totals.

Inputs and results
Inputs
Target length per run in m, manufacturer cut interval in mm, rounding direction, whole run count and optional matching lm/m, W/m and LEDs/m.
Results
Cut intervals and actual length per run, shortfall or excess, total cut length and optional lm, W and LED counts on the supplied strip-rating basis.

Browse all lighting tools