How to compare lighting specifications

Read lumens, watts, colour temperature and other lighting specifications together, and recognise when two product data sheets are not comparable.

Two lights can have the same wattage and give different amounts of light. They can also have the same lumen rating and produce quite different results over a kitchen bench. A useful comparison starts with the task you want to light, then checks what each product’s figures actually describe.

Keep the original data sheets open while you compare. Record the exact model and selected settings, rather than combining the largest output and lowest power figures from different variants.

What do lumens and watts tell you?

Lumens (lm) describe luminous flux: the amount of light output. Watts (W) describe electrical input power. Watts alone do not tell you how much light a product produces, and lumens do not tell you the illuminance at a particular point on a bench or floor.

First check whether the stated lumens belong to a lamp or LED light source, or to the complete luminaire. A luminaire is the lighting fitting as a whole. Its optics and other components can affect the light leaving it. Do not treat a light source’s lumen figure as the measured output of the complete fitting.

When is lm/W meaningful?

Luminous efficacy expresses light output per watt of electrical input. For a complete luminaire, divide its stated output in lm by its corresponding input in W. Both figures must describe the same model and operating setting, on the same whole-luminaire basis.

For an invented example, 900 lm at 9 W gives 100 lm/W. Another invented example, 1200 lm at 9 W, gives about 133.33 lm/W. These figures illustrate the arithmetic; they are not product specifications or recommended targets.

That comparison describes output per watt under the stated conditions. It does not establish which product suits a room or activity. Different beam distributions, colour characteristics and installation conditions still matter.

What if the driver power or operating setting is unclear?

Look for input power for the complete luminaire, including its required driver. Check whether the output and power refer to the same CCT selection and power setting. A selectable fitting may have several combinations; a range on a sales page does not establish one matching pair.

If the basis remains unclear, record the original figures and the question you need answered. Ask the manufacturer or supplier for the corresponding whole-luminaire data. Leaving efficacy uncalculated is more useful than producing a precise-looking figure from mismatched inputs.

The Lighting Product Comparison follows this boundary. It records lamp or unknown-level data, but only calculates efficacy for complete luminaires when you declare the matching basis. Your declaration is not an independent verification of the data sheet.

Does colour temperature tell you how bright a light is?

No. Correlated colour temperature (CCT), expressed in kelvin (K), describes the colour appearance of suitable white light. A lower CCT is commonly described as warmer; a higher CCT as cooler. CCT is not a lumen rating or a measure of illuminance.

Record the actual kelvin value rather than relying only on names such as warm white or cool white. If a product offers several settings, keep the available choices and identify which setting the other specifications describe. Do not use a different CCT setting’s output figure without noting that difference.

Choose the colour appearance with your activity and surroundings in mind. The comparison tool records your requirements; it does not select a colour temperature for you.

What do CRI, beam angle and dimensions add?

These attributes answer different questions. Keep them alongside output and power instead of reducing them to one overall score.

What does the CRI statement describe?

Colour rendering index (CRI) describes aspects of colour rendering. Preserve the manufacturer’s stated metric, including a label such as Ra and any qualifier such as “≥90”. A single CRI figure does not describe every aspect of light quality or establish that two products will make every colour look the same.

What does the beam angle describe?

Record the beam angle in degrees and retain the manufacturer’s definition or distribution notes. A beam angle helps describe how light is distributed; it is not the boundary of an evenly lit area and does not tell you whether a task surface receives enough light.

Two products with equal lumens but different distributions can put different amounts of light on the same task. Position, distance, obstructions and the surrounding surfaces also affect the result.

Do matching dimensions prove a fitting will fit?

No. Record cut-out and overall dimensions separately, with their units. Dimensions are useful for identifying differences, but the manufacturer’s installation instructions can include other requirements.

A matching cut-out alone does not establish clearance, insulation coverage, mounting suitability or electrical compatibility. Keep those questions for the applicable product instructions and installation assessment.

Does “dimmable” mean it will work with your dimmer?

It means you need more information about the intended combination. Record the exact luminaire, driver and dimming statement, then check the manufacturer’s information for the proposed control equipment and conditions.

The word “dimmable”, a matching total wattage or a shared brand name is not sufficient evidence of compatibility. The comparison tool keeps the statement visible; it does not approve a dimmer or predict its performance.

What can this comparison not tell you?

A table of product specifications cannot determine the illuminance across a room, shadows at your work position, glare or the quality of a complete lighting design. Those questions need further information about the space, the task, the products and their placement.

It also cannot approve wiring, wet-area use, insulation coverage or compliance with an Australian installation or lighting requirement. Neither a high lm/W figure nor a completed comparison changes that boundary.

Use the comparison to identify a meaningful difference or an unanswered question. For example, you might discover that one data sheet lists only source lumens, or that a selectable product does not state output for your intended setting. Those are useful reasons to obtain clarification before choosing.

How can you compare two product data sheets?

  1. Write down the activity and any requirements you already know. Keep unknown requirements visible rather than inventing a target.
  2. Identify each exact model and retain its original data-sheet address.
  3. Record the operating setting and whether the figures describe the complete luminaire or its light source.
  4. Copy the available specifications with units and qualifiers. Leave missing values blank.
  5. Only use a lumen-and-watt pair for efficacy when its whole-luminaire basis matches.
  6. Review the differences and missing information against your task. Seek the relevant product or project advice for questions the table cannot answer.

Start with the two-product comparison. For how Aulumens handles input conditions and missing information, see Methodology.

Use the related calculator