“Four to one” needs a measurement definition
A key-to-fill contribution ratio and a bright-to-dark total ratio can have different values for the same setup. The distinction starts with what was measured: each light separately, or the total light on two sides of a subject.
With separate compatible readings K for key-only and F for fill-only, the contribution ratio is K/F. Only under the additional model that fill reaches both sides equally and key adds solely to the bright side does the bright-to-dark ratio become (K + F)/F. The extra one is a consequence of that declared fill contribution, rather than an adjustment that belongs to every ratio.
If the readings already describe bright-side total and dark-side total, divide them directly. Adding one again would count light that is already included.
Metered f-numbers must be squared
At the same ISO and shutter time, nominal metered f-number squared is proportional to the compatible exposure quantity. Two readings of f/8 and f/4 therefore correspond to 64/16 = 4:1, rather than 2:1. The signed first-to-second stop difference is log₂(ratio).
This squared relationship is also why compatible flash exposure contributions are added as squared f-numbers in the Flash Guide Number Calculator. Scantips’ direct-flash discussion supplies the corresponding guide-number and exposure context. A display’s electrical-power percentage is a different quantity and does not establish light at the subject.
Flash share needs a common exposure window
Flash and ambient contributions can be compared when they describe compatible light exposure integrated over the same camera exposure window and receiver basis. For example, artificial linear contributions of 3 units from flash and 1 unit from ambient give a flash-to-ambient ratio of 3:1 and a flash share of 3/(3 + 1) = 75%.
Instantaneous ambient illuminance in lux cannot be divided by an unmatched flash exposure reading to obtain that share. Changing shutter time can change the ambient contribution, so keep the chosen exposure window in the measurement record. Sekonic’s meter specifications distinguish ambient and flash measurement tasks; their existence does not make every pair of readings comparable.
Zero readings and measurement geometry
A genuine zero linear contribution remains zero. If the second contribution is zero, there is no finite first-to-second ratio or logarithmic stop difference. If both flash and ambient are zero, the flash share is undefined rather than 0%. A zero f-number is not a valid metered aperture and is rejected.
Keep receiver position, orientation, measurement quantity and operating conditions comparable. The bright/dark option requires the bright reading to be at least the dark reading so that the labels retain their meaning. These ratios describe the supplied measurements and explicit fill model; they do not predict skin-reflection pixel values or choose a preferred artistic lighting style.